Tuesday, August 5, 2008

The Roles, Models and Influences of Email on Education

The use of email communication in the field of education has many positive and negative influences. Email communication has changed the ways students and faculty communicate in the educational environment. This increased usage of email communication produces resources and barriers with regard to the modes of communication within the educational field. The purpose of this section is to explore the modes of communication that email can transform, the creative new learning styles that can develop from emailing, and the positive and negative aspects of utilizing email in the educational field.
In comparing traditional communication styles to email communication, there are many different characteristics that can be defined. There are roles of communicating with an audience such as the sender and receiver; and there are also the delivery modes such as the message and the channel. (Burnett & Marshall, 2003a) The channel of communication discussed for this part of the study is email with regard to education. Email enables messages to be sent and received over the internet using various different models of communication. There is the one-to-one model of communication in which one sender sends an email to one receiver. (Burnett & Marshal, 2003a) This is often compared to face-to-face interaction in the traditional way of communicating. There is a one-to-many model of communication which is when one sender sends a message to many receivers. (Burnett & Marshal, 2003a) For example, there are many instructors who teach online courses and want to send one message that applies to all students. The instructor can create an email message and send the message to all the students enrolled in the course. This is a many-to-one model of communication which is when many senders send their messages to one receiver. In the educational environment, especially in an online course, many students or senders can send their messages, questions or concerns about the course material to the instructor who is the single receiver. The fourth model of communication is the many-to-many which are when any sender and receiver can access mass messages that are stored for individuals to select or retrieve. (Burnett & Marshal, 2003a) An example of this model of communication is when individuals form work groups or virtual teams in an online class and the students need to communicate with each other. The individual students can create email messages to each individual in the group. In this case, everyone in the group has access to select, retrieve, or reply to the email messages that have been sent. These are the examples of the different models of communication that occur when using email to communication in education.
With regard to the field of education, the usage of email communication has some negative and positive influences. Email has become a popular and convenient way of communicating. In a study about the attitudes of email and the likelihood of future users among university freshmen, more than half of the freshmen in college using email during their first semester were very encouraging. (Elasmar & Carter, 1996) Many students in college become familiar with using email and its basic mechanisms. There are a large number of students who use email; however there are anxiety factors that students have when they are first introduced to using the technology and resources that email offers. One factor that can be a cause for concern is when educational institutions implementing email systems in their curriculum. (Elasmar & Carter, 1996) This study suggests that in order to increase email usage among college students there has to be assistance of real people and online support when questions and conflicts arise during the usage of email communication. (Elasmar & Carter, 1996) The study also suggests that the use of email should be encouraged in a playful environment to increase familiarity and comfort but concerns about the degrees of privacy can sometimes cause negative perceptions about using email communication. (Elasmar & Carter, 1996) These are some positive and negative aspects to be aware of when using email in the educational environment, especially because it’s become such a crucial communication channel in the educational environment.
The use of email enables creative new learning styles in the educational field. For example, a ninth-grade English teacher and an undergraduate English instructor created a partnership in which their students used email communication to discuss their views about a book titled To Kill a Mockingbird. (Borsheim, 2004) The use of email communication created an online conversation about the literature that was being studied in each of the classrooms. The college students were studying about the opportunities for social interaction using technology and the high school teacher wanted her students to see things from other points of view. (Borsheim, 2004) In this new learning style using email, the ninth grade students benefited by receiving positive feedback, support on their thoughts, opportunities to explore and articulate ideas, boast confidence in comprehension and presentation, and engage in real conversations while asking intellectual questions. (Borsheim, 2004) Some people may argue that email conversations take away from face-to-face interactions that students need in a classroom environment. However, from this approach of instruction the educators stated that the email conversations did not replace classroom discussions, it enhanced the classroom discussions. (Borsheim, 2004) There are many other creative ways that email communication has enhanced learning in the field of education and assisted in developing new and creative learning styles.
Email communication has changed the way we communicate within the field of education. The traditional models of communication can help us understand how email communication applies to these models and channels which allow individuals to send and receive messages. Within these models of email communication, there are some negative and positive aspects when communicating online. Although, there are some negative aspects to email communication, there are still opportunities to create new learning styles with the use of email in education. Email is just one form of online communication; there are various programs and software that educational institutions utilize to communicate with their students.

References:

Borsheim, C. (2004). Email Partnerships: Conversations That Changed the Way My Students Read. English Journal. (High School Edition) Urbaba: Vol 93, Iss 5. Pg 60 , 60-66.
Burnett, R., & Marshal, P. (2003a). Web of Technology. Web Theory: An Introduction. , 7-22.
Elasmar, M., & Carter, M. (1996). Use of e-mail by college students and implications for curriculum . Journal and Mass Communication Educator. Columbia: Vol. 51, Iss 2; pg 46 , 46-54.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

The subject is so important now a day. I am very thankful for CMC in education without it I would not have been able to accomplish as much as I have in school. Email really does help communication between students and teachers. This blog really covered all the points and there is not much left to say but I agree with you. I cannot stress how gratifying it is to have such a wonderful technology. Bargh & McKenna (2004) say, “e-mail was considered as useful as face-to-face interactions for getting work done” (p.579). This is so very true and at times, I think it is actually even better. None of us would have been able to take these classes online if it was not for CMC. Also being able to talk to your teachers in between classes is a lifesaver. Therefore, I am glade we have CMC it makes education so much better in most ways.


Bargh, J.A., & McKenna, K.Y.A. (2004). The internet and social life. Annnual Review of Psychology, 55, 573-590.