Tuesday, August 5, 2008

Introduction to CMC in Education


With the world becoming increasingly technology-based, it is nearly impossible to avoid the changes that come with the use of new technological resources. In fact, since computers and the Internet have become “the utility of the masses rather than the plaything of computer scientists,” (Wellman, 2004, p. 125) CT has become an increasingly important tool for human communication. One of the most highly affected aspects of society with regard to this increase in computer-mediated communication (CMC) is the field of education. Educators’ worldwide have turned to new technology in order to broaden the spectrum of learning, most commonly in university settings. For the most part, the changes have been well-received-“in the Jones (2002) national survey, 60% of college students reported that the internet had been beneficial to their relationships with classmates,” as well as in their communication with teachers and ability to learn via the Internet. (Bargh and McKenna, 2004, p. 579)

There are various CT tools that college students use to further their education. A few of these tools will be discussed more specifically throughout the additional sections of this blog. These tools include e-mail which is arguably the most commonly used method of communicating online and has fueled student to student as well as faculty asynchronous-distributed communication, making for easier communication between members of the academic community. Blackboard, a home-base for students that grants individuals the ability to access their courses through the Internet while staying connected with other students and faculty members in between classes and over academic breaks, and SafeAssignment which is an online database that students can utilize to submit their assignments. Safeassignment is not only beneficial to student involvement but it also helps instructors quest to ensure that academic integrity is not compromised as education moves further into the digital age. All of these tools are different and each has positive and negative qualities but they share a common goal which is to increase the ease and effectiveness of CMC in education.

References

Bargh, J.A., & McKenna, K.Y.A. (2004). The internet and social life. Annnual Review of Psychology, 55, 573-590.

Wellman, B. (2004). The three ages of Internet studies: Ten, five and zero years ago. New Media and Society, 6, 123-129.

The Roles, Models and Influences of Email on Education

The use of email communication in the field of education has many positive and negative influences. Email communication has changed the ways students and faculty communicate in the educational environment. This increased usage of email communication produces resources and barriers with regard to the modes of communication within the educational field. The purpose of this section is to explore the modes of communication that email can transform, the creative new learning styles that can develop from emailing, and the positive and negative aspects of utilizing email in the educational field.
In comparing traditional communication styles to email communication, there are many different characteristics that can be defined. There are roles of communicating with an audience such as the sender and receiver; and there are also the delivery modes such as the message and the channel. (Burnett & Marshall, 2003a) The channel of communication discussed for this part of the study is email with regard to education. Email enables messages to be sent and received over the internet using various different models of communication. There is the one-to-one model of communication in which one sender sends an email to one receiver. (Burnett & Marshal, 2003a) This is often compared to face-to-face interaction in the traditional way of communicating. There is a one-to-many model of communication which is when one sender sends a message to many receivers. (Burnett & Marshal, 2003a) For example, there are many instructors who teach online courses and want to send one message that applies to all students. The instructor can create an email message and send the message to all the students enrolled in the course. This is a many-to-one model of communication which is when many senders send their messages to one receiver. In the educational environment, especially in an online course, many students or senders can send their messages, questions or concerns about the course material to the instructor who is the single receiver. The fourth model of communication is the many-to-many which are when any sender and receiver can access mass messages that are stored for individuals to select or retrieve. (Burnett & Marshal, 2003a) An example of this model of communication is when individuals form work groups or virtual teams in an online class and the students need to communicate with each other. The individual students can create email messages to each individual in the group. In this case, everyone in the group has access to select, retrieve, or reply to the email messages that have been sent. These are the examples of the different models of communication that occur when using email to communication in education.
With regard to the field of education, the usage of email communication has some negative and positive influences. Email has become a popular and convenient way of communicating. In a study about the attitudes of email and the likelihood of future users among university freshmen, more than half of the freshmen in college using email during their first semester were very encouraging. (Elasmar & Carter, 1996) Many students in college become familiar with using email and its basic mechanisms. There are a large number of students who use email; however there are anxiety factors that students have when they are first introduced to using the technology and resources that email offers. One factor that can be a cause for concern is when educational institutions implementing email systems in their curriculum. (Elasmar & Carter, 1996) This study suggests that in order to increase email usage among college students there has to be assistance of real people and online support when questions and conflicts arise during the usage of email communication. (Elasmar & Carter, 1996) The study also suggests that the use of email should be encouraged in a playful environment to increase familiarity and comfort but concerns about the degrees of privacy can sometimes cause negative perceptions about using email communication. (Elasmar & Carter, 1996) These are some positive and negative aspects to be aware of when using email in the educational environment, especially because it’s become such a crucial communication channel in the educational environment.
The use of email enables creative new learning styles in the educational field. For example, a ninth-grade English teacher and an undergraduate English instructor created a partnership in which their students used email communication to discuss their views about a book titled To Kill a Mockingbird. (Borsheim, 2004) The use of email communication created an online conversation about the literature that was being studied in each of the classrooms. The college students were studying about the opportunities for social interaction using technology and the high school teacher wanted her students to see things from other points of view. (Borsheim, 2004) In this new learning style using email, the ninth grade students benefited by receiving positive feedback, support on their thoughts, opportunities to explore and articulate ideas, boast confidence in comprehension and presentation, and engage in real conversations while asking intellectual questions. (Borsheim, 2004) Some people may argue that email conversations take away from face-to-face interactions that students need in a classroom environment. However, from this approach of instruction the educators stated that the email conversations did not replace classroom discussions, it enhanced the classroom discussions. (Borsheim, 2004) There are many other creative ways that email communication has enhanced learning in the field of education and assisted in developing new and creative learning styles.
Email communication has changed the way we communicate within the field of education. The traditional models of communication can help us understand how email communication applies to these models and channels which allow individuals to send and receive messages. Within these models of email communication, there are some negative and positive aspects when communicating online. Although, there are some negative aspects to email communication, there are still opportunities to create new learning styles with the use of email in education. Email is just one form of online communication; there are various programs and software that educational institutions utilize to communicate with their students.

References:

Borsheim, C. (2004). Email Partnerships: Conversations That Changed the Way My Students Read. English Journal. (High School Edition) Urbaba: Vol 93, Iss 5. Pg 60 , 60-66.
Burnett, R., & Marshal, P. (2003a). Web of Technology. Web Theory: An Introduction. , 7-22.
Elasmar, M., & Carter, M. (1996). Use of e-mail by college students and implications for curriculum . Journal and Mass Communication Educator. Columbia: Vol. 51, Iss 2; pg 46 , 46-54.

SafeAssignment's Impact on CMC in Education



It’s apparent that as new technology emerges, it affects every area of life that it touches. One of the areas most heavily influenced by technological advances in our society is the world of education. Computer technology is making enormous impacts on traditional methods of schooling. as it changes the makeup of institutions across the board. According to Bargh and McKenna (2004), “73% of American college students now use the Internet more than their university library,” (p. 577). With this rapid switch to the use of technologically-based methods of researching, it appears as though the information highway would skyrocket the learning curve. That being said, this increase in technology and resources can also create additional concerns with regard to academic integrity. With a simple cut and paste, students could easily cheat their way to a degree without anyone knowing. This is just one reason why such easily accessible and shared information worries some individuals within academic institutions. A new tool, however, has been implemented in an attempt to help institutions ensure that the work their students submit is either original or cited correctly. This tool is called SafeAssignment and it is currently being used across the country to fight plagiarism. With this application, students upload their writing assignments to be checked against a database, making sure that the woek was onot copied from a website or another paper that has previously been uploaded. Not only does the program check for copying, but it also ensures that any direct quotes or paraphrasing is cited correctly in the assignment. The teacher of the course is then given a SafeAssignment “Originality Report” that shows if the work is the students’ own. Here is a useful website to explain more about how SafeAssignment works, as well as why Arizona State University chooses to use the system:

https://techbase.asu.edu/wiki/index.php/SafeAssignment

SafeAssignment, one of the many innovations that holds incredible “value as a technological classroom tool to teachers of communication,” (Wood and Fassett, 2003, p. 287), is finally allowing professors to use the convenience of computer-mediated communication to their advantage. Classes can now be held strictly online, with assignments submitted through SafeAssignment which ensures that teachers don’t have to be concerned about the integrity of what they are receiving. Some scholars, however, believe that “today, at the dawn of the Information age, many commentators are asking for an entire reconstruction of the education system,”(Ezer, 2006, p. 202). As this shift continues happening at such a rapid pace, many educators and students alike are finding it increasingly difficult to keep up with the advancements in technology. SafeAssignment is helpful for those who use it, but does it give those who don’t a disadvantage? Either way, it is clear that this technology offers more options for an increasingly CMC based world.

References

Bargh, J.A., & McKenna, K.Y.A. (2004). The internet and social life. Annnual Review of Psychology, 55, 573-590.

Ezer, J. (2006). Gandhi’s third assassination: Information and communications technology education in India. Information Technology for Development, 12, 201-212.

SafeAssignment. (2008). Retrieved August 2, 2008 from the World Wide Web: https://techbase.asu.edu/wiki/index.php/SafeAssignment

Wood, A., & Fassett, D. (2003). Remote control: Identity, power, and technology in the communication classroom. Communication Education, 52, 286-296.

Blackboard as a Component of CMC Education

Blackboard as a Component of CMC Education

As the world evolves so do the communication techniques, strategies and resources that individuals rely on. The continual influx of technology and different media outlets in society continue to transform the ways that people communicate with regard to school, work, and personal life. In terms of education, the internet has provided crucial resources which enable individuals to take courses and pursue degrees from a distance. One of these resources is Blackboard which is a widely adopted Course Management Software (CMS) tool used in education at all levels, from k-12 through higher education, as well as in professional schools such as the dental, medical, and business education. The literature suggests that Blackboard as a means of communication in education has both positive and negative effects on the overall learning experience.
As stated by Larry, Griffeth and Hartman (2007), “Blackboard was developed in conjunction with faculty members at Cornell University as a course management system for education.” Overall “Blackboard Academic Suite is a comprehensive engagement and assessment solution that grows as your institution grows. It enables you to increase faculty adoption of technology for teaching, drive student engagement through personalized experiences and active learning tools, securely share and collaborate around content across the institution and meet diverse assessment needs of institutions.” (http://www.blackboard.com/products/Academic_Suite/index) These elements provide a platform to students, teachers and faculty which enable and encourage growth on all levels of the academic institution. Blackboard can be a vital resource which individuals can utilize to fulfill their needs and aspirations. The technology continues to grow as increasing amounts of academic institutions aim to create further learning opportunities within the online environment.
As stated by Jackson (2007) “Nationwide, academic librarians are looking for ways to enhance student learning in this web-based environment and ultimately increase the information literacy skills of college graduates.” Blackboard is a key component to this online learning migration as it offers students opportunities to become educated in ways that were never available in a more traditional learning environment. The resources that this technology offers are nearly boundless and can be extremely beneficial for individuals who cannot attend classes in person. Utilizing Blackboard grants individuals access to complete course materials, take exams and communicate with teachers and other students across a variety of media applications. As said by Jackson (2007) “While web-based systems need not be a replacement for face-to-face contact with students, learning management systems provide another avenue to enhance student learning and set graduates on the path to lifelong learning.”
Though there are many positive aspects of the Blackboard CMS, there are negative sides to the technology as well. “Disadvantages are that if someone does not always check Blackboard, after a change has been made to an assignment, they may complete the assignment improperly. Also, if there is a problem with the network, and Blackboard or another class site is not working, a student may not be able to hand in an assignment on time, even though it has been completed.” (http://weblogs.ucalgary.ca/ajkroman/blog/2007/03/19/blackboard_pros_and_cons)
This can be especially difficult for individuals who are still new to the internet or are not technologically savvy. Along with the possibilities of computer glitches, other significant disadvantages center around the issues of displacement, socialization, and a lack of interpersonal communication. As stated by Bugeja (2005), “Without interpersonal intelligence, we are never really sure of our roles, responses, and emotions.” (p. 36) Many individuals have a difficult time communicating in the physical classroom, and this can translate to the online environment as they may find themselves unable to express themselves effectively as well as unable to develop social connections. This can lead to increased shyness, anxiety, and increased separation. These different levels of technological ability can impact the quality of performance and projects and lead to potential difficulties with regard to group involvement and timing considering that each individual is participating based on their own schedules.
In conclusion, the literature shows that Blackboard CMS technology has both benefits and shortcomings. As mentioned above, the positives include increased learning options, flexibility to accommodate students on their individual schedules, and robust technological applications. Less positively, Blackboard is not universally comfortable for all students to use, should not be considered a substitute for other means of teaching and learning and, as with all technology, is dependent on the Internet and other connectivity working well. As a study conducted by Larry, Griffith and Hartman (2007) suggests “Academic institutions are devoting substantial amount of money, resources and time into web enhanced teaching under the belief that adding Web substance to a class enhances the learning experience for students. However, there has been no comprehensive examination of faculty perceptions of and reactions to web-based learning tools and in particular the use of Blackboard, its usefulness and ease of use.” It would be interesting and helpful for enhancing CMC education to see what such research would indicate.

References

Landry, B. J. L., Griffeth, R., & Hartman, S. (2006). Measuring student perceptions of
Blackboard using the Technology Acceptance Model. Decision Sciences Journal
of Innovative Education, 4(1), 87-99.

Blackboard. (2008). Retrieved July 30, 2008, from the World Wide Web:
http://www.blackboard.com/products/Academic_Suite/index

Jackson, P. A. (2007). Integrating information literacy into blackboard: building
campus partnerships for successful student learning. Journal of Academic
Librarianship, 33, 454-461.

University of Calgary. (2007). Retrieved July 30, 2008, from the World Wide Web:
http://weblogs.ucalgary.ca/ajkroman/blog/2007/03/19/blackboard_pros_and_cons
Bugeja, M. (2005). Displacement in the global village. In, Interpersonal divide: The search for community in a technological age. New York: Oxford.

Conclusion

Communication is a crucial aspect to society’s ability to function. As stated by Bargh and Mckenna (2004), “Information and Communication technology shapes our perceptions, distributes our pictures of the world to one another, and constructs different forms of control over the cultural stories that shape our sense of who we are and our world”. This is no different with regard to the world of academia. The CMC tools in education discussed throughout this blog share common goals which all work towards an increase in the ease and effectiveness of learning and receiving information across the world of education. Although, these tools share a common goal there are negative and positive factors when it comes to the use of CMC in education. The tools that are discussed in this blog include the use of email in education, the tool of SafeAssignment, and Blackboard as a component in education. The positives aspects for using email in education are that it can make communication a playful environment which makes learning fun. Is also opens the door for creativity when communicating between members within the educational system. Some negative aspects of using email in education is that it may caused stress and anxiety for new users, this is especially found in freshmen behavior in a higher education institution. The use of email in education is increasing in every educational institution across the nation as some institutions even assign each student with an email address. In making communication more effective with email, educational institutions have also implemented a tool called SafeAssignment which helps protect them against plagiarism and helps increase integrity. The use of this tool is no different from turning in quality work in the classroom environment. The positive aspect of SafeAssignment ensures quality work and original ideas. A negative aspect of SafeAssignment is that some individuals may be behind on CT and could suffer from the creation of a wider digital divide. Despite the negative and positive aspects of SafeAssignment it is becoming a growing trend. The SafeAssignment system is used with the Blackboard system in education. Blackboard is a component in the world of online education which offers students to become interactive learners outside of the traditional classroom environment. Some positive aspects of using blackboard are that it gives people opportunity to learn outside the classroom especially for those who cannot attend class and it grants complete access to students making a one stop shop for information, assignments, quizzes, tests, and more. Some negative aspects of using Blackboard are that students do not always check the system which makes keeping up with the course difficult. Blackboard can also be difficult for first time users of the Internet or those who are not technology savvy. Regardless of the benefits and shortcomings of this technology, blackboard is becoming widely used in the educational field. Each one of these tools attempts to make communication easier and more effective in the educational field. A commonality between all these tools is that they are becoming trends which are widely used in the educational system. The developments of these tools are part of a revolution of the increasing use of communication technology.

References

Burnett, R., & Marshal, P.D. (2003b). The web of technology. In, Web Theory: An Introduction. New York: Routeledge